Patricia Crone & Michael Cook HAGARISM The Making of the Islamic World HAGARISM THE MAKING OF THE ISLAMIC WORLD PATRICIA CRONE SENIOR . Donor challenge: Your generous donation will be matched 2-to-1 right now. Your $5 becomes $15! Dear Internet Archive Supporter,. I ask only. That is one reason why copies of “Hagarism”, Ms Crone’s first book, long out of print, now sell for hundreds of dollars. It was published in

Author: Mukazahn Tejinn
Country: Algeria
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Medical
Published (Last): 8 February 2011
Pages: 215
PDF File Size: 12.39 Mb
ePub File Size: 5.52 Mb
ISBN: 674-9-52895-277-8
Downloads: 50596
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Grohn

Thus the Hagarenes contrived to create a religion of their own and decided to splinter off from Judaic practices and beliefs. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here The other major source of perturbation in the sacred geography of Arabia was the search for a suitable scenario for the Mosaic activities of the Prophet. The impact of foreign conquest on this variety of small-scale identities was correspondingly destructive.

May many read this book and of the many, may a few be called and raised up as new Crones, Cooks, and Wansbroughs, to carry on the work valiantly commenced herein. These two chapters serve to provide a brief background on these lands and their intellectual and religious climates prior to the Islamic conquest. This double intrusion did something to knit the Greek world together, but it left it a long way from becoming a western Iran.

As the Hagarenes broke with their erstwhile Jewish proteges and ac- quired large numbers of Christian subjects, their initial hostility to Christianity was clearly liable to erosion. Marwan in the s, and the latter ‘s love of the Christians. The dilemma of the Syrians was thus analogous to that of their Punic cousins in North Africa, who had similarly managed to hang on to a tenuous ethnic and linguistic distinctiveness without much else: Second, the interpretation of Balaam’s complimentary remarks to the Kenite as the expression of his personal anti-Israelite sentiment is quite improper: There is however one particular group of readers who are in a special position.


Just because the rabbis had the scriptural resources for their gemara, their Karaite opponents could hope to make a viable legal position of what one might call their reduction of mishna to midrash.

In the first place, Hellenism had an abundance of adherents beyond its ethnic frontiers; the Greeks could thus be conquered by their own cultural tributaries, where the Iranians could suffer this fate only at the hands of their ideological enemies. But how much older is it? But Rabbula believed so that he might be cured, and obeyed so that he might be redeemed; he sold his wordly goods to rid himself of demons, and crucified both flesh and intellect to beatify his heaven.

Then as now an urban elite and a Hellenised priesthood coexisted with a native tradition: Egypt did, of course, have an aristocracy thanks to the third-century administrative reforms. Fascinating look at the context of the early history of Islam. Farzana rated it it was amazing Sep 11, Please try again later. Cover of the first edition. For this we have to turn to the earliest connected account of the career of the Prophet, that given in an Armenian chronicle written in the 66os and ascribed to Bishop Sebeos.

On the one hand, the numismatic, documentary and architectural remains of this period manifest a new and assured religious persona. Crone’s two most known works concentrate on this topic: Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam.

Despite the metropolitan features of Medina, this is the solution to which the Islamic tradition substantially inclines. But whereas neither Jewish nor Christian literature provides satisfactory precedent for the Islamic usage, 32 we find exact parallels in the most important Samaritan text of thepre- Islamic period.

Reviews of Hagarism by Patricia Crone and Michael Cook | Islamic Studies

Shafi’i disputing with those who reject all traditions for the Koran ibid. The Hagarenes had achieved a new, independent and effective solution to a central dilemma of learned monotheism; and with this their undignified clientage to the peoples they had conquered was finally at an end. Part of the confusion arises from the fact that Cook and Crone have made no manifest effort to repudiate their juvenile findings in the book. Their work has presented the Koran as “a scripture with a history”, as Patricia Crone said in a interview in The Atlantic Monthly.


Already in an account of a disputation between a Christian patriarch and a Hagarene emir which probably took place in ,” the emir appears neither to reject nor to affirm the messianic status of Jesus.

Hence islam replaced hijra as the fundamental religious duty, 40 and the ‘Mahgraye’ accordingly became Muslims.

A wide variety of results come about, which range from an outright rejection of certain pre-Islamic ideas to an absorption of others into Islamic thought as seen for example in the case of Iranian political ideas. But at the same time this dual civilisation meant a dual tension. The main text of the book is comprised of fourteen chapters that are divided neatly into three main parts: The New York Times.

In Iran, by contrast, the twinship of religion and kingship was historically aboriginal and doctrinally unproblematic; and the legitimation of the monarchic government of a settled society carried with it the legitimation of the aristocratic substructure that goes with it. It is always helpful in determining what primary sources to use in studying early Islamic history.

Follow the Author

The religion of Abraham was thus the most appropriate locus for the assimilation and development of the borrowing, and the Koranic material bears out this inference. Pages to import images to Wikidata All articles with unsourced statements Articles with unsourced statements from January At times nearly incomprehensible.

It was probably aimed at the academic reader, so my criticism may be unfair. The history of the transmission of the oral tradition between the Prophet and the eight- century scholars was still grarifyingly plastic.